Introduction
The Eastern Tropical Pacific (ETP) has a warm pool characterized by high temperature and low salinity surface waters with a strong-shallow pycno and thermocline (Fiedler & Lavín, 2017; Fiedler & Talley, 2006). This habitat supports a biological diversity that includes reef-building corals, plankton communities, fishes, marine mammals, and birds, among others. Salinas Bay is located a few kilometers north of the Gulf of Papagayo. Climate drivers and forcers are the same in both places, with very similar seasonal cycles (Alfaro & Cortés, 2012; Alfaro et al., 2012; Amador et al., 2006; Amador, Durán-Quesada, et al., 2016; Amador, Rivera, et al., 2016). The dimensions of Salinas Bay are small and being in a position such that its axis is east-west, it is directly influenced by the exit towards the Pacific of the Papagayo jet, which flows in the lowlands south of Nicaragua and north of Costa Rica with a predominantly northeast direction (Amador et al., 2006). Therefore, primary productivity is affected by seasonal upwelling events in Salinas Bay, as is the case in at least three other coastal areas of the ETP: the gulfs of Tehuantepec, Papagayo and Panama (Amador et al., 2006). The upwellings are caused by wind forcing over the sea surface near the coast, at gaps where transisthmian wind jets reach the Pacific through topographic depressions of the mountain range (Amador, Rivera, et al., 2016; Fiedler & Lavín, 2017). Those wind jets are generated by northeasterly trade winds and easterlies winds that increase atmospheric pressure in the Caribbean (Amador, Durán-Quesada, et al., 2016; Kessler, 2006; Willet, Leben, & Lavín, 2006). The upwellings take place during boreal winter, which corresponds to dry season in the Central American Pacific slope (Amador et al., 2006), and they reach their maximum intensity between February and March (Brenes, Lavín, & Mascarenhas, 2008). The cold fronts in the boreal winter intensify trade winds, strengthening the Papagayo wind jet, which forces the coastal upwelling (Alfaro & Cortés, 2012; McCreary, Lee, & Enfield, 1989; Zárate-Hernández, 2013). Furthermore, Intertropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ) migration southward favors the predominance of northeasterly trade winds in Central America during the dry season (Brenes & Gutiérrez, 1998). The ETP is also under the influence of interannual variability sources, such as the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) warm/cold cycle (Alexander, Seo, Xie, & Scott, 2012; Fiedler & Lavín, 2017). Interannual variability impact on sea surface temperature (SST) anomalies, in upwelling regions in the Central American Pacific, is mainly attributed to ENSO (Alfaro & Lizano, 2001). Alfaro et al. (2012) found a relationship between warm events in Culebra Bay, Gulf of Papagayo, and anomalies in the Niño 3.4 index.
The development of an upwelling is evidenced by the spatial and seasonal dynamics of the thermocline depth and the thermohaline pattern in the water column (Brenes & Gutiérrez, 1998; Fiedler & Talley, 2006). D’Croz and O’Dea (2009) consider that the upwelling is “one of the most pervasive hydrological events to influence the shelf waters of Pacific Central America”. Intense winds displace sea surface water offshore and set up vertical mixing in the surface layers of the sea, allowing colder thermocline and subthermocline water to rise toward the surface, which results in lower SSTs and higher salinity concentrations (Alfaro & Cortés, 2012; Brenes, Hernández, & Gutiérrez, 1998; Kessler, 2006; Willet et al., 2006). CTD data measured by a research cruise, between February and March 1994, exposed the upwellings in the Gulf of Papagayo and Gulf of Panama, where high salinity cold tongues surrounded by warm waters were observed on the surface (Brenes et al., 2008). According to Loza-Álvarez, Benavides-Morera, Brenes-Rodríguez, and Saxon Ballestero (2018), temperatures were lower and salinity concentrations were higher in a sampling carried out in the Gulf of Papagayo during the dry season than in another sampling during the wet season. In hydrographic stations at the ETP during March, there was a notable elevation of the thermocline associated with the strong Papagayos winds (Mora-Escalante, Lizano, Alfaro, & Rodríguez, 2020). In the Gulf of Papagayo, high concentrations of nutrients, carbon dioxide (CO2) and phytoplankton from the subsurface chlorophyll maximum emerge into the euphotic zone during the upwelling, increasing local chlorophyll production (Ballestero & Cohen, 2004; Willet et al., 2006; Rixen, Jiménez, & Cortés, 2012). Loza-Álvarez et al. (2018) also found that chl-a maximum at 35 m in the rainy season was replaced by a homogeneous distribution with higher chl-a concentrations in shallow waters during the dry season, as a consequence of the turbulent mixture caused by the winds and the upwelling processes. At Panama Bay, the upwelling displaces nutrient-poor surface water with cooler, more saline and nutrient rich waters (D’Croz & Robertson, 1997). In the Gulf of Panama, increases in chl-a and dissolved oxygen concentrations were observed at the surface, followed by oxygen-poor waters below the thermocline and higher turbidity, as a result of upwelling events (D’Croz & O’Dea, 2007, D’Croz & O’Dea, 2009).
The alterations in the physico-chemical parameters of the water caused by the upwellings affect biological populations. Increases in nutrient availability triggers phytoplankton blooms (Stuhldreier, Sánchez-Noguera, Rixen, et al., 2015); however, in the Gulf of Papagayo, Stuhldreier, Sánchez-Noguera, Roth, Jiménez, et al. (2015) observed that at the Matapalo reef the upwelling did not influence the benthic community. Wizemann et al. (2018) found that carbonate bioerosion increased with the upwelling in that same area. However, Rixen et al. (2012) determined that in Culebra Bay, Gulf of Papagayo, the negative impact of the upwelling on coral growth might be counteracted by high nutrient concentrations. Sanchéz-Noguera et al. (2018) suggest that corals in Culebra Bay are adapted to upwelling effects, in accordance with Stuhldreier, Sánchez-Noguera, Roth, Cortés, et al. (2015). In fact, Jiménez, Bassey, Segura, and Cortés (2010) described coral habitats in the Gulf of Papagayo, since most of the coastal area is suitable for coral reef growth despite the upwelling influence. Conversely, the conditions are not suitable for the growth of coral reefs in Panama Bay due to upwelling effects, according to D’Croz and Robertson (1997). Increases in nutrient concentrations caused by upwelling events in ETP are associated with the expansion of opportunistic species in coral reefs (Roth, Stuhldreier, Sánchez-Noguera, Carvalho, & Wild, 2017). Regarding the study area of this research, Sibaja-Cordero and Cortés (2008) detected a seasonal change of algal assemblages in the rocky intertidal zone related to the upwelling in Salinas Bay. Moreover, Cortés, Samper-Villarreal, and Bernecker (2014) discovered that the growth rate of an algae, Sargassum liebmannii, peaked during seasonal upwelling in Salinas Bay.
Summing-up, within the ETP areas of contrast are created between upwelling and non-upwelling zones, as well as seasonality, which defines the marine ecology of the Central American Pacific. As a result, a study of the spatial and temporal dynamics of the physical parameters in Salinas Bay is necessary to understand the influence of upwelling events on the hydrology and biology of the bay. Accordingly, the objective of this research is to produce the first report of the spatial and temporal dynamics of temperature, density, salinity, oxygen, chl-a and turbidity in Salinas Bay, Costa Rica, based on the analysis of CTD cast data measured through 33 one-day oceanographic campaigns, between August 2008 and December 2014, and relate the CTD warm and cold events to the observed atmospheric conditions.
Materials and methods
Study area: Salinas Bay is located on the northwest of Costa Rica and is shared with Nicaragua. This region is exposed to a seasonal upwelling that starts in December and ends in April-May. There are small coral patches, constructed by the zooxanthellate corals. Filtering organism are some of the main components of the rocky bottoms, including several species of ascideans, sea cucumbers, polychaets and octocorals (Cortés, 2016). Eight hydrographic stations were sampled along a latitudinal transect 11.8 km long, at 11.06 ºN latitude and between 85.67º W and 85.79º W longitude (Fig. 1).
Measurements and analyses: A CTD database made up of 215 data-points was compiled from the results of 33 one-day oceanographic campaigns, conducted in Salinas Bay between August 2008 and December 2014 (Table 1). The physical parameters of the water were measured with a CTD model SBE 19plus V2, which was calibrated under the manufacturer’s standards. In some campaigns, it was not possible to obtain measurements for all the stations and/or variables and certain data measured were excluded because they were not reliable. After the analysis of maximum and minimum values listed in Table 2, Table 3, Table 4, Table 5, Table 6 and Table 7, data from the closest station to the coast (VIII) were discarded from this research, since it was too shallow and sampling could not be done some times or the data were unreliable. The maximum depth sampled in each station fluctuates for the different campaigns due to variations in sea level that could be caused by environmental conditions, such as the tide and the season. As a result, an approximation of the maximum depth was used for data plots (Fig. 2, Fig. 3, Fig. 4, Fig. 5, Fig. 6, and Fig. 7). The approximate maximum measurement depth at station I was 50 m, at station II 45 m, at station III 35 m, at station IV 25 m, at station V 19 m, at station VI 18 m and at station VII 10 m.
Year | Month | |||||||||||
Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec | |
2008 | 20 | 25 | 4 | |||||||||
2009 | 19 | 23 | 18 | 20 | 22 | |||||||
2010 | 7 | 6 | 24 | 19 | 21 | 10 | ||||||
2011 | 24 | 14 | 23 | 18 | 8 | |||||||
2012 | 15 | 25 | 14 | 23 | 18 | 5 | ||||||
2013 | 13 | 18 | 13 | 5 | ||||||||
2014 | 20 | 12 | 18 | 4 |
Station | Maximum | Minimum | ||||
Temperature (°C) | Date | Depth (m) | Temperature (°C) | Date | Depth (m) | |
I | 29.76 | 18/6/2009 | -1 | 15.15 | 24/2/2011 | -53 |
II | 29.60 | 18/6/2009 | -1 | 15.84 | 24/2/2011 | -45 |
III | 29.35 | 18/6/2009 | -1 | 16.50 | 18/4/2013 | -37 |
IV | 29.93 | 18/6/2009 | -7 | 17.45 | 13/2/2013 | -25 |
V | 29.49 | 20/8/2008 | -1 | 17.21 | 13/2/2013 | -18 |
VI | 29.70 | 18/6/2009 | -6 | 17.11 | 13/2/2013 | -17 |
VII | 29.86 | 18/6/2009 | -4 | 17.38 | 13/2/2013 | -10 |
Station | Maximum | Minimum | ||||
Density (kg m-3) | Date | Depth (m) | Density (kg m-3) | Date | Depth (m) | |
I | 26.00 | 24/2/2011 | -53 | 19.83 | 21/10/2010 | -2 |
II | 25.83 | 18/4/2013 | -46 | 19.67 | 23/8/2012 | -8 |
III | 25.64 | 18/4/2013 | -37 | 19.73 | 21/10/2010 | -2 |
IV | 25.38 | 13/2/2013 | -25 | 19.61 | 21/10/2010 | -2 |
V | 25.56 | 13/2/2013 | -18 | 19.67 | 21/10/2010 | -1 |
VI | 25.47 | 13/2/2013 | -17 | 19.74 | 21/10/2010 | -2 |
VII | 25.53 | 13/2/2013 | -10 | 19.72 | 21/10/2010 | -1 |
Station | Maximum | Minimum | ||||
Salinity (PSU) | Date | Depth (m) | Salinity (PSU) | Date | Depth (m) | |
I | 34.88 | 18/4/2013 | -3 | 31.70 | 21/10/2010 | -2 |
II | 35.03 | 13/2/2013 | -1 | 31.58 | 21/10/2010 | -1 |
III | 35.15 | 23/4/2009 | -2 | 31.59 | 21/10/2010 | -2 |
IV | 34.99 | 13/2/2013 | -3 | 31.48 | 21/10/2010 | -2 |
V | 35.56 | 23/4/2009 | -2 | 31.53 | 21/10/2010 | -1 |
VI | 35.49 | 23/4/2009 | -1 | 31.60 | 21/10/2010 | -2 |
VII | 35.15 | 13/2/2013 | -1 | 31.60 | 21/10/2010 | -1 |
Station | Maximum | Minimum | |||||
Oxygen (ml l-1) | Date | Depth (m) | Oxygen (ml l-1) | Date | Depth (m) | ||
I | 4.88 | 23/6/2011 | -16 | 0.17 | 14/4/2011 | -53 | |
II | 4.82 | 23/6/2011 | -3 | 0.30 | 14/4/2011 | -47 | |
III | 4.91 | 5/12/2013 | -3 | 0.64 | 20/3/2014 | -36 | |
IV | 5.02 | 5/12/2013 | -1 | 1.81 | 20/3/2014 | -24 | |
V | 5.10 | 14/4/2011 | -15 | 1.78 | 20/3/2014 | -17 | |
VI | 5.12 | 14/4/2011 | -8 | 1.89 | 20/3/2014 | -17 | |
VII | 5.61 | 5/12/2013 | -8 | 2.13 | 23/6/2011 | -10 |
Station | Maximum | Minimum | |||||
chl-a (mg m-3) | Date | Depth (m) | chl-a (mg m-3) | Date | Depth (m) | ||
I | 4.57 | 4/12/2014 | -6 | 0.01 | 13/6/2013 | -44 | |
II | 4.88 | 4/12/2014 | -7 | 0.01 | 23/8/2012 | -3 | |
III | 5.06 | 4/12/2014 | -6 | 0.02 | 18/8/2011 | -3 | |
IV | 4.24 | 4/12/2014 | -6 | 0.03 | 23/8/2012 | -4 | |
V | 4.79 | 4/12/2014 | -7 | 0.05 | 18/8/2011 | -4 | |
VI | 4.84 | 4/12/2014 | -7 | 0.07 | 13/2/2013 | -17 | |
VII | 4.04 | 4/12/2014 | -5 | 0.02 | 23/8/2012 | -1 |
Station | Maximum | Minimum | ||||
Turbidity (NTU) | Date | Depth (m) | Turbidity (NTU) | Date | Depth (m) | |
I | 3.13 | 18/9/2014 | -53 | 0.02 | 14/4/2011 | -52 |
II | 2.45 | 5/12/2012 | -46 | 0.04 | 14/4/2011 | -36 |
III | 1.89 | 5/12/2012 | -37 | 0.04 | 14/4/2011 | -34 |
IV | 1.87 | 4/12/2014 | -27 | 0.09 | 14/4/2011 | -26 |
V | 3.02 | 23/8/2012 | -18 | 0.17 | 12/6/2014 | -1 |
VI | 2.87 | 23/8/2012 | -17 | 0.21 | 13/2/2013 | -1 |
VII | 3.67 | 23/6/2011 | -9 | 0.35 | 13/2/2013 | -1 |
The variables processed for analysis were temperature, density, salinity, oxygen, chl-a and turbidity. The raw data were downloaded from the CTD and subjected to a series of processes included in Sea-Bird Electronics SBE Data Processing software that converted the raw data to engineering units, subjected to a low-pass filter some columns of the data, aligned the data relative to pressure, performed conductivity thermal mass correction, deleted inaccurate values, calculated the derive variables, averaged the data every meter deep, generated the data to ASCII files and plotted preliminary profiles of the variables. Regarding derived variables, the density of seawater and practical salinity were computed with SBE software from CTD measurements (Sea-Bird Electronics, 2016). Dissolved oxygen concentration computation was based on values measured by a polarographic membrane oxygen sensor model SBE 43, which counts the number of oxygen molecules per second through the membrane (Sea-Bird Electronics, 2013). Chl-a and turbidity were measured with the ECO-FL-NTU model fluorometer and scattering sensor, which determines the fluorescence and the suspended particle concentration in the water (Sea-Bird Electronics, 2011; Sea-Bird Electronics, n.d.). For the oxygen, chl-a and turbidity data, it was necessary an additional visual quality control procedure in order to manually delete unreliable data, since these values were inconsistent or out of the nominal ranges of measurement of the sensors.
After data processing, a Python code (Van Rossum & Drake, 2009) was created to obtain the maximum and minimum values of each variable along with the corresponding date and depth, and the results were stored in tables separated by variable (Table 2, Table 3, Table 4, Table 5, Table 6, and Table 7). A code was written in MATLAB® (MATLAB®, 2018) to plot Hovmöller diagrams (Fig. 2, Fig. 3, Fig. 4, Fig. 5, Fig. 6, Fig. 7), which reveal the temporal distribution that each variable presented during the studied interval. Maximum and minimum values in Tables 2 to 7, retrieved with the Python code, were used to define the respective color scales for each map. A Hovmöller kind diagram was plotted for each of the seven hydrographic stations and six variables, resulting in a total of 42 diagrams.
The annual cycle of the CTD variables were then calculated as the average values for all the stations and depth levels for a particular month. Also, the climate values from a meteorological station located in Santa Elena, La Cruz, Guanacaste (10°54’59” N, 85°36’59” W, altitude: 270 masl, Fig. 1, https://www.imn.ac.cr/mapa) were considered to represent the annual cycle of the air surface temperature (maximum, mean, minimum), precipitation, and wind magnitude. The climatology of the sea subsurface temperature in a station located in Salinas Bay (11º01.616’ N, 85º45.801’ W, depth: 3.3-4.9 m) described in Alfaro and Cortés (2021) was also included (see Fig. 8a in the next section).
Results
Temperature: The thermocline is located around 30 m. Vertical temperature distribution has a periodic variability, where cold cycles fit with dry seasons and warm cycles with rainy seasons (Fig. 2). Temperature variability for all stations was similar, but with slight differences, mainly due to depth near the coast. The minimum temperature registered was 15.15 °C in station I at approximately the maximum depth in February 2011, and the maximum temperature, 29.93 °C, was observed in station IV at 7 m in June 2009 (Table 2).
Density: Density variability presents the same periodicity as temperature, but with an inverse relation (Fig. 3). Water masses were denser during upwelling events and at greater depths. Less dense water is observed mostly at shallow layers and during the rainy season. Sigma-t density ranged from 19.61kg m-3, in station IV at 2 m in October 2010, to 26.00kg m-3, in station I at approximately the maximum depth in February 2011 (Table 3).
Salinity: Salinity had a seasonal variability with higher values found in the dry season (December-April) and lower during the rainy months (May-November). The variation in salinity was observed mainly within the first 25 m and at deeper layers tended to be stable (Fig. 4). Salinity ranged from 31.48 PSU in station IV at 2 m in October 2010, to 35.56 PSU in station V at 2 m in April 2009 (Table 4). Throughout the entire time series, salinity at depths of 25 m and below was higher than 34 PSU, except between April and December 2012, when a warm episode took place.
Oxygen: Dissolved oxygen had higher values within the first 30 m depth with concentrations around 3-5 ml l-1 (Fig. 5). Annual variability associated with the upwelling was not so clear for oxygen, however, the tendency was for higher concentrations of dissolved oxygen during the rainy season when compared with the dry season. The lowest value for dissolved oxygen was 0.17 ml l-1 in station I at approximately the maximum depth in April 2011, and the highest was 5.61 ml l-1 in station VII at 8 m in December 2013 (Table 5). Oxygen did not show a strong seasonal variability and therefore the interannual signal dominated.
Chl-a: High concentrations of chl-a were predominant in the first 25 m and when the upwelling was active (Fig. 6). Maximum chl-a concentration, of 5.06 mg m-3 was found in station III at 6 m in December 2014, during an upwelling event. On the other hand, chl-a minimum took place in station I at 44 m, during rainy season in June 2013 (Table 6). The interannual signal was predominant for chl-a dynamics, as a consequence of the weak seasonal variability.
Turbidity: Turbidity did not have an evident periodic tendency associated with upwelling, as is the case for other parameters, but there were areas with higher turbidity, mainly at the bottom of different stations during rainy season (Fig. 7). Turbidity values ranged from 0.0184 NTU in station I at approximately the maximum depth in April 2011, to 3.6706 NTU in station VII at 9 m in June 2011 (Table 7). Turbidity dynamics depended mainly on the interannual signal, since its seasonal variability was also weak.
Annual Cycle: Figure 8 shows the monthly mean values of the CTD variables described above, plus the air surface temperature (maximum, mean, minimum), precipitation, wind magnitude and sea subsurface temperature. Sea subsurface temperature minimum was observed in February-March, with a relative minimum in July between the two maxima of May-June and September-October (Fig. 8a). Maximum and minimum air temperature presented their lowest values in October-November and January-February and the highest in March-April and July, respectively. Mean air temperature is a combination of the maximum and minimum annual cycles, with maximum and minimum in April and the quarter of October-November-December (Fig. 8b). Precipitation presented a typical bimodal distribution of the Central American Pacific slope, with a dry season in December-April and a rainy season with two maxima in May-June and September-October, with a reduction in July-August associated with the Mid-Summer Drought (Fig. 8c). Wind magnitude presented high values for the boreal winter, from December to March and low values in June, September and October. A relative maximum is observed for July (Fig. 8d). The annual cycle of the temperature and salinity from the CTD casts tend to covariate in opposite way. From December to April, high (low) salinity (temperature) values were observed, meanwhile from May to October respectively, high (low) temperature (salinity) values were reported (Fig. 8g). Density annual cycle responds to the salinity and temperature ones, with high values from December to April and low values from May to October (Fig. 8e). Oxygen, chl-a and turbidity were minimum in April. Chl-a and turbidity presented a peak in June and the oxygen in December (Fig. 8f, Fig. 8g, Fig. 8h).
Discussion
Temperature: Absolute maximum temperature was observed within shallow waters at 7 m, as is expected for warmer water masses. Maximum for all stations, except for V, occurred in June 2009, which is in accordance with a warm event recorded by Alfaro et al. (2012) at Culebra Bay, where a SST standardized anomaly of 0.64 ºC was observed. June corresponds to the rainy season when SSTs in the ETP are expected to be warmer and the upwelling is not active. According to the Costa Rican National Meteorological Institute (IMN in Spanish) weather bulletin, during June 2009 warm event atmospheric mean temperatures and maximum absolute temperatures in the Pacific region were higher than the historic mean (Quirós, 2009). Maximum for station V occurred in August 2008, under the influence of a persistent warming of the SSTs in the equatorial ETP, and a positive anomaly of temperature offshore Costa Rican North Pacific coast, according to IMN bulletin (Sánchez, 2008). Minimum absolute and for stations I-II was observed during a cold event in February 2011, associated with a cold front and a high-pressure system, which accelerated winds speed and favored upwelling (Morera, 2011). Minimum for station III took place in April 2013, a month characterized by pressure anomalies due to polar air masses and cold fronts that increased winds intensity (Chinchilla, 2013). Minimum for stations IV to VII was observed in February 2013, under dry conditions, the incidence of cold fronts and the predominance of strong northeast winds (Morera, 2013b). The Oceanic Niño Index (ONI) 3-month running mean (3-MRM) anomalous SST for periods that include the observation of the absolute maximum temperature and of the maxima temperatures at all stations (except V) were neutral for April-May-June and May-June-July but warm for June-July-August period (0.5 ºC 3-MRM). The ONI values for all periods that include the maximum of station V were neutral. The absolute maximum and stations I and II maxima were observed during cold events in accordance with the ONI index (-1.4 ºC for December-January-February, -1.2 ºC for January-February-March and -0.9 ºC for February-March -April). ONI values were neutral for all the periods that cover the observation of the minima at stations III to VII (Climate Prediction Center, n.d.).
Density: Absolute maximum density was observed at Station I at approximately the maximum depth, during a cold event caused by a high-pressure in February 2011 (Morera, 2011), when temperature minima was observed. Stations II and III registered the maximum in April 2013, influenced by pressure anomalies due to polar air masses and cold fronts which increased winds intensity (Chinchilla, 2013). Maximum for stations IV-VII occurred in February 2013, with dry conditions, the incidence of cold fronts and the predominance of strong northeast winds (Morera, 2013b). Absolute minimum in October 2010 is associated with shallow depths as it was found at 2m in station IV, during the wet season when upwelling is not present or is very weak. It should be noted that according to Figure 8c, September and October are the rainiest months in the region. Besides, atmospheric temperature maxima were higher than the historic mean (Solano, 2010). In general, heat flux at ETP tends to be lower during the wet season since the presence of the cloud tops caused by the displacement of the Inter-Tropical Convergence Zone reduces solar radiation incidence over sea surface (Amador, Rivera, et al., 2016). Nevertheless, during the rainy season SSTs at Salinas Bay are warmer given that the upwelling is inactive, resulting in lower water densities locally. The other stations registered density minimum the same day that station IV at a depth between 1-2 m, with the exception of station II where density minimum was observed in August 2012 at 8 m. This condition could be related to a warming event, which started in April-May and peaked in June-July, due to the increase in the air temperatures and SST (Poleo & Stolz, 2012a). In addition, the North Pacific of Costa Rica presented a positive precipitation anomaly, rain was greater than normal, and trade winds weakened in August as a result of the weakening of the North Atlantic Anticyclone, resulting in unfavorable conditions for an upwelling as is expected during the rainy season (Poleo & Stolz, 2012b).
Salinity: Higher salinities were observed during upwelling events, associated with colder and denser waters. Absolute maximum was located in station V in shallow waters (2 m), and is related to a high-pressure system, which caused a cold front that accelerated trade winds in April 2009, favoring the upwelling, which is also the case for stations III and VI maximum (Alfaro, 2009). Maximum for station I occurred in April 2013, under the influence of pressure anomalies due to polar air masses and cold fronts that strengthened trade winds (Chinchilla, 2013). Maximum for stations II, IV, and VII happened in February 2013, a month characterized by dry conditions, the incidence of cold fronts and the predominance of strong northeast winds (Morera, 2013b). Minima for all stations were observed in October 2010, during the wet season, as in the case of density. The observed seasonal dynamics for salinity is consistent with observations made in the Gulf of Papagayo, where lower salinity concentrations during the rainy season are associated with increased rainfall (Loza-Álvarez et al., 2018).
Oxygen: Absolute maximum oxygen concentrations were observed at 8m, only a few meters above the maximum chlorophyll layer, in December 2013, a month characterized by strong trade winds (Morera, 2013a). Stations III-IV and VII maxima coincide temporally with absolute maximum. In the case of stations I-II, maximum occurred in June 2011, under fast winds on the Pacific coast and short periods with dry conditions (Morera & Stolz, 2011). For stations V-VI the maximum was observed in April 2011, a windy month with dry conditions, influenced by cold fronts (Chinchilla, 2011a). Absolute minimum was registered in April 2011, but it is related to a high depth reached at station I rather than synoptic conditions, since oxygen constantly decreases with depth. The above applied for station II, where the minimum was observed at approximately the maximum depth the same date. In stations III-VI the minimum was located near the bottom in March 2014, a dry month with high pressures and persistent trade winds (Solano, 2014). Minimum for station VII was also located near the seabed, in June 2011 during wet season, whereby it is more related to depth than to weather conditions.
Chl-a: Absolute maxima of chl-a were recorded in December 2014, a month when four cold fronts, which generated strong trade winds and wind gust speed over 100km h-1, were observed locally (Chinchilla, 2014). However, this event was aborted by an easterly wind burst in the western Pacific, which led to an event of El Niño (Levine & McPhaden, 2016). Maxima for all stations was registered in the same date. Chl-a concentrations tend to increase during upwelling, associated with an increase in biological productivity, and are higher in the thermocline. Absolute minimum was observed in station I, within deep waters, at 44 m in June 2013, under typical wet season conditions (Poleo & Stolz, 2013). In the case of stations II, IV and VII, the minimum was observed in August 2012, a month characterized by weak trade winds, a rainy pattern above the historic records for the North Pacific and atmospheric temperatures warmer than the historic mean associated with an El Niño (Poleo & Stolz, 2012b). Minimum for stations III and V occurred in August 2011, with the incidence of wet conditions due to wind from the west, which fostered rainy activity in Guanacaste (Chinchilla, 2011b). Station VI minimum was observed in February 2013 under dry conditions (Morera, 2013b), whereby it is associated with depth (17 m) rather than synoptic conditions.
Turbidity: In some stations a periodicity in turbidity was observed, with remarkable increases close to the seabed during wet seasons. Absolute maximum was registered in station VII in June 2011, during a short dry period within the rainy season, with above normal wind speed in the Pacific, weak trade winds and atmospheric temperatures above the historic mean (Morera & Stolz, 2011). At station I the maximum occurred in September 2014, when trade winds weakened in Guanacaste favoring an increase in humidity, and low-pressure systems resulted in extreme events, particularly on September 13 and 18 (sampling day), fostering intense precipitations in the region (Poleo & Stolz, 2014). In addition, during that month the influence of El Niño affected the weather in the region (Alvarado, 2014b). For station II-III, the maximum appeared in December 2012, with predominance of trade winds and less cold fronts than usual (Solano, 2012). For station IV the maximum was registered in December 2014, a month characterized by indirect incidence of cold fronts and strong trade winds, particularly during an important event the first ten days, which was present when the sampling was carried out on the fourth day (Chinchilla, 2014). Also, El Niño was active during December 2014 after intensifying in previous months (Alvarado, 2014a). The maximum in stations V-VI happened in August 2012, with the presence of El Niño, weak trade winds and positive anomalies of atmospheric temperatures and precipitation (Poleo & Stolz, 2012b). Absolute minimum was found in April 2011, in the presence of a cold front, which caused moderate wind (Chinchilla, 2011a). Minimum for stations I-IV occurred the same month. For station V the minimum was recorded in June 2014, when the North Pacific was experiencing a drought associated with El Niño (Naranjo, 2014). The minimum for stations VI and VII occurred in February 2013, a month affected by windy conditions due to cold fronts (Morera, 2013b). The heterogeneity of atmospheric conditions at the moment when maxima or minima values were presented does not allow to conclude a relation between turbidity, synoptic conditions and the upwelling, since the values do not have a seasonal periodicity. Most maxima values were observed when an event of El Niño was active, which could indicate a relation between them; however, a minimum was also registered during an El Niño event. All of the maxima were located at the seabed of their respective stations. In the case of the minima, only those presented in April 2011 are located in the bottom of the stations, and turbidity levels remained low within the entire water column.
Annual Cycle relationships: Density annual cycle presented high values from December to April, in agreement with the dry season in the Central American Pacific slope and with the months in which the magnitude of the wind is also high (Amador et al. 2006). This season is associated with high incoming solar radiation, important evaporation, low cloudiness, sea water transport offshore, minimum runoff and a deeper mixing layer (Amador, Durán-Quesada, et al., 2016; Durán-Quesada et al., 2020). During December-April, density is consequently associated with high salinity values and low sea temperatures of the water column in Salinas Bay. Oxygen, chl-a and turbidity were minimum in April, in which the air surface temperature was maximum. From May to October occurs the rainy season, increasing the runoff-freshwater input to the bay and the cloud cover. Additionally, the wind magnitude decreases along with the evaporation, the sea water transport offshore and the depth of the mixing layer. These factors increased the Salinas Bay sea water temperature and reduce its salinity. Oxygen presented a positive trend from the begin to the end of the rainy season, when the wind magnitude and the air surface temperature presented negative trends. Chl-a and turbidity presented a peak in June, in agreement with the first part of the rainy season. Turbidity also presented a relative maximum in October. These turbidity peaks could be related with the sediment runoff transport during the peaks of the rainy season. June chl-a peak could be associated with the high incoming solar radiation and low wind magnitude values observed during the mornings of the rainy season (Alfaro et al., 2012), but the relative maximum in December could be associated with a decrease in the cloud coverture (Amador et al., 2006).
Conclusions
Our results in Salinas Bay, should be interpreted in the context of the Eastern Tropical Pacific seasonal and interannual variability described in detail by previous works of Amador et al. (2006); Amador, Durán-Quesada, et al. (2016), Amador, Rivera, et al., (2016) and Durán-Quesada et al. (2020). The spatial and temporal dynamics of the hydrology in Salinas Bay was influenced by the coastal upwelling events, as its effects include lower SSTs, higher salinity and density, and the movement of dissolved inorganic nutrients toward the surface, leading to favorable conditions for biological blooming and increasing chlorophyll-a concentrations, as it was observed in February 2013. The periodicity of oxygen, chl-a, and turbidity is not as remarkable as with the other variables, but it can be associated with the seasons. The climatic conditions influenced the appearance of maximum and minimum values for the variables. For example, rainy patterns above the historic records, as the June 2013, could be associated with observed minima of chl-a in some stations. The region also presented an interannual variability, such as that associated with ENSO, which can counteract the upwelling during warm events such as the identified cases of August 2008 and June 2009.
Cold fronts and high-pressure anomalies associated with polar air masses are the main synoptic conditions related to temperature and turbidity minima (except in station V) and density, salinity and chl-a maxima, given that these conditions strengthen the winds that favor the upwelling in the studied region. Moreover, atmospheric and sea surface positive temperature anomalies, positive precipitation anomalies, weak trade winds and the influence of El Niño are the principal meteorological conditions for temperature and most of turbidity maxima and density, salinity, and chl-a minima (except in station VI). Turbidity maxima at stations II, III and IV were recorded under strong trade winds but with a lower incidence of cold fronts and, in the case of station IV maximum, during an event of El Niño. As a result, seasonal and interannual variability can counteract their effects on the oceanographic parameters when they temporally coincide. Both oxygen maximum and minimum were measured during the upwelling but, oxygen minima were related to depth rather than synoptic conditions.
Annual and interannual variation observed in Salinas bay influences the local ecosystem and that is reflected in the growth of algae (e.g., Sargassum), as reported by Cortés et al. (2014). According to Morales-Ramírez, Till-Pons, Alfaro, Corrales-Ugalde, & Sheridan-Rodríguez. (2021), zooplankton in Salinas Bay responds in accordance with changes in the structure of the oceanographic conditions modulated through the seasonal upwelling in the region. Compared to other coastal areas in the Costa Rican North Pacific, Salinas Bay seems to be a healthy local ecosystem.
Ethical statement: authors declare that they all agree with this publication and made significant contributions; that there is no conflict of interest of any kind; and that we followed all pertinent ethical and legal procedures and requirements. All financial sources are fully and clearly stated in the acknowledgements section. A signed document has been filed in the journal archives.